Nantucket is a tiny island in the state of Massachusetts and is about 30 miles away from Cape Cod. As a small island, it has an entirely different vibe from what you would expect to get when in mainland Massachusetts.
Unlike Boston, the capital of the state, Nantucket allows visitors to experience a more traditional and nautical stay. It’s the perfect destination for beautiful views of the ocean, delicious authentic New England fare, exploring fantastic nature, and grand tours to discover the history of Nantucket’s whaling legacy.
Undeniably the best thing to do in Nantucket is to try all the food possible. After all, this is where you can find some of the finest local and international cuisines in the country. Be prepared for fresh seafood like steamed lobster, fried clams, and the iconic New England clam chowder that defines the region.
If you are not a big fan of seafood, go for a delicious plate of authentic Italian, French or Asian fusion, or check out the local steakhouses. For an alternative experience of Nantucket’s food lifestyle, you could always try delicacies from artisanal bakeries, gourmet markets, or even go for a tour at Nantucket’s famous breweries and distilleries. After all, the island is often associated with the coastal wine trail, so expect to try some exceptional curated wine lists.
Furthermore, at Nantucket, apart from having numerous choices in cuisines, you can choose from several different dining styles. You can delve into high-end fine dining at prestigious estates or enjoy the island’s many seasonal spots that offer culinary treats from spring through autumn.
But of course, Nantucket, as a laid-back and chill place, also provides several casual dining restaurants that create an enjoyable experience with good food and a relaxing ambiance.
Best Restaurants in Nantucket
Straight Wharf Restaurant
If you want to visit one of the best seafood restaurants in America, then this is your destination. Straight Wharf has been serving delicious elevated seafood dishes with exceptional local wine for over 45 years.
The restaurant is situated in downtown Nantucket by the waterfront at one of the bustling piers. As it sits in the heart of the harbor district, the restaurant successfully fuses traditional seafood heritage with modern, sustainable cooking methods.
Since the restaurant is seasonal and focuses on sustainability, there is always something fresh to look forward to. They serve only the daily catch combined with local produce, classic cocktails, and local brews.
Why you should dine at Straight Wharf:
- This restaurant has been consistently named one of America’s top seafood destinations by Travel & Leisure and Food & Wine.
- The service and ambience strike a perfect balance between high-end elegance and harbor-side comfort.
Diner’s note: The dining room typically offers a prix-fixe menu. For a more casual, a la carte experience, try the Bar Grill. Reservations open up early in the season and fill quickly.
CRU Nantucket Oyster Bar
If you are looking for a vibrant and iconic dining destination, then CRU is a must-visit. It is one of the premier seafood spots in Nantucket, located at the very end of Main Street on the waterfront. It offers mesmerizing views of the harbor and the luxury yachts docked nearby.
CRU features a chic, sleek interior and a seafood-forward menu with a spectacular raw bar. Their chilled lobster cocktail and world-famous lobster rolls are the highlights of the menu.
The menu incorporates Mediterranean elements, ensuring the dishes are light, healthy, and flavorful. To fully enjoy your meal, be sure to pair your oysters with a selection from their expertly curated wine and champagne list.
Why you should dine at CRU:
- It is widely considered the “see and be seen” spot of Nantucket harbor.
- It has one of the most stunning waterfront views on the whole island.
- They serve some of the freshest oysters you can find, literally steps from the dock.
Diner’s note: This is one of the toughest reservations to secure. Reservations are usually handled through Resy and go live 14 days in advance. It is a high-end experience, so plan your budget accordingly.
Galley Beach
Galley Beach opened back in the 1920s as a simple clam shack and has evolved into one of the most prestigious beachfront restaurants in the world. With its 100-year history, Galley Beach is a true historical icon of the island.
This is premier beachfront dining at its finest. The venue features an elegant, coastal-chic design with a relaxed, toes-in-the-sand luxury feel. The open-air dining room provides breathtaking views of the Nantucket Sound, especially during the legendary sunsets.
Whether for a sunset cocktail or a refined dinner, Galley Beach provides an unforgettable atmosphere. Their wine cellar holds over 5,000 bottles, ensuring a perfect pairing for their signature seafood dishes.
Why you should dine at Galley Beach:
- Oprah Winfrey famously called Galley Beach the best place to get married on the East Coast.
- It has hosted Presidents and celebrities for decades, cementing its status as a top-tier Nantucket destination.
The Nautilus
The Nautilus offers a high-energy formal dining experience with a unique “shared plates” concept. The ideology here is that everything is designed to be enjoyed together, fostering a social and communal atmosphere.
Inspired by Asian street food and Mediterranean flavors, the menu takes you on a global journey. While seafood-heavy, it also features incredible meat dishes and traditional New England ingredients reimagined.
Beyond the food, their award-winning sake, wine, and spirits selection is a major draw. The Nautilus provides a vibrant, modern dining experience that stands out from the more traditional island spots.
Why you should dine at Nautilus:
- The restaurant offers a unique fusion of Japanese Izakaya style and global coastal cuisine.
- The small-plate format allows you to sample a wide variety of innovative flavors in one sitting.
Diner’s note: The restaurant is typically closed on Mondays. Reservations are highly sought after and usually become available 14 days in advance at 10 am via their website.
Millie’s
Located on the far end of the island in Madaket, Millie’s is well worth the 20-minute drive or the scenic bike ride from downtown. It offers a cozy, casual vibe with high-quality, approachable food that is perfect for families.
The restaurant features picnic-style outdoor seating and a relaxed indoor space. It is the perfect spot to unwind after a day at the nearby beaches. Their menu specializes in Baja-style tacos, quesadillas, and lobster rolls.
Don’t leave without trying their signature “Madaket Mystery” cocktail—it’s a local legend for a reason!
Why you should dine at Millie’s:
- Their menu perfectly blends California surf-shack flavors with classic New England seafood.
- It offers one of the most relaxed and family-friendly atmospheres on the island.
Diner’s note: Millie’s is open seasonally (typically May through October). During your visit, stop by Millie’s Market next door for great Nantucket-themed merchandise and apparel.
Oran Mor
If you want to immerse yourself in the historical charm of the island, Oran Mor is the perfect destination. Located in a historic building with nautical decor and antiques, it captures the true spirit of Nantucket.
This upscale bistro offers both a refined bar and elegant dining rooms. The menu is constantly evolving based on the changing seasons and local harvests, proving that thoughtful simplicity is often the height of luxury.
They serve exceptional handcrafted cocktails and feature a wine list that highlights both local gems and world-renowned vintages.
Why you should dine at Oran Mor:
- It is an upscale bistro with one of the most sophisticated cocktail programs on the island.
- They offer innovative takes on classics, such as their legendary pasta dishes and local lamb.
Diner’s note: They are typically closed Tuesdays and Wednesdays. Reservations are highly recommended and can be booked easily online.
Dune Restaurant & Bar
Dune offers one of the most exciting and consistent menus in downtown Nantucket. Since opening in 2009, it has established itself as a premier destination for modern American cuisine.
The decor across the three dining rooms fuses elegance with island coziness. The quartzite bar and the charming patio provide a sophisticated backdrop for their expansive cocktail and wine lists.
Dune’s menu changes with the seasons, ensuring that the finest local fish and meats from regional farms are always featured. It remains a favorite for those seeking high-quality dining in a refined yet comfortable setting.
Why you should dine at Dune:
- It features a highly creative menu that showcases the best of New England’s land and sea.
- Their patio is one of the most pleasant spots in town for a summer evening.
Diner’s note: Dune is open year-round (with brief winter breaks). Dinner service typically starts at 5 pm. Reservations are recommended during the peak summer months.
Ventuno
Ventuno is widely considered the best Italian restaurant on the island. While the exterior looks like a traditional Nantucket home, the interior and the flavors will transport you to a high-end bistro in Italy.
They offer elevated takes on Italian classics, with a heavy emphasis on fresh, handmade pasta and local seafood. The atmosphere is sophisticated and energetic.
A highlight of Ventuno is its delightful outdoor “Back Bar,” which is a local favorite for aperitivo hour and late-night cocktails under the stars.
Why you should dine at Ventuno:
- They serve the most refined Italian cuisine on the island, including exceptional artisanal pasta.
- The wine list is extensive, featuring both prestigious Italian labels and local favorites.
Diner’s note: Typically open for the season from May through October. Reservations are essential for the dining room.
Proprietors Bar and Table
Proprietors Bar and Table focuses on globally-inspired small plates, making it the perfect spot for sharing a meal with a group. The name is a tribute to the island’s original “proprietors” during the whaling era.
The restaurant is a leader in the island’s craft cocktail culture. The food menu combines international spices and techniques with the freshest in-season Nantucket ingredients.
It offers a sophisticated yet laid-back vibe that captures the modern spirit of the island’s historic downtown.
Why you should dine at Proprietors:
- The shared-plate format is ideal for adventurous eaters and groups.
- It is frequently recommended by national publications like Conde Nast Traveler and Vogue for its unique culinary identity.
Diner’s note: Typically open 5 days a week (closed Tuesdays and Wednesdays). Reservations are highly recommended and can be made via their website.
Island Kitchen
Island Kitchen is the premier spot for a casual yet high-quality brunch. Located a short walk from the downtown core, it provides a welcome break from the busiest tourist areas.
While famous for brunch, it also features a cozy ice-cream parlor and a vibrant cocktail lounge. The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, but the food quality remains high enough to rival the island’s fine-dining establishments. The service is consistently cheerful and efficient.
Their menu is inspired by classic American and New England traditions, with frequent innovative fusions.
Why you should dine at Island Kitchen:
- It is arguably the top-rated brunch spot on the island.
- The attached ice cream parlor makes it a favorite for families and kids.
Diner’s note: They typically serve breakfast/brunch daily from 7 am to 2 pm, and dinner from 5:30 pm to 9:30 pm. Their “IK Counter” on Main Street is perfect for a quick snack while shopping downtown.
Related Read: 16 Things to Do in Martha’s Vineyard
What’s the Best Restaurant For You?
Family Restaurants
If you are looking for big groups, children’s options, or a social atmosphere, these are your best bets:
- Island Kitchen (Best for kids & ice cream)
- Millie’s (Relaxed beach vibe)
- Proprietors Bar and Table (Great for sharing)
- The Nautilus (High-energy social dining)
Romantic & Special Occasion Restaurants
For an intimate evening with a significant other or a picturesque celebration, choose:
- Galley Beach (Best sunset views)
- CRU (Harbor-side glamour)
- Straight Wharf (Classic island elegance)
- Ventuno (Cozy Italian charm)
Also Read: 20 Best Romantic Wines for Any Occasion
Casual & High Value
If you want delicious food without the formal dress code or premium price tag:
- Millie’s
- Island Kitchen
Overall, Nantucket remains a premier global destination for food and wine lovers. Whether you are seeking a 100-year-old beachfront icon or a modern Asian-fusion hotspot, this tiny island delivers a world-class dining experience.